TRoy Research: one trend rule, many markets

Our own research. The rule is simple: hold a market while its price is above its 200-day average, step aside when it falls below. One market on its own has long quiet stretches and sharp drops. Doing the same on many different markets at once spreads the risk: when one market falls, others are usually still rising. Here are the results, how we tested them, and a live version you can change yourself.

1. Test results (run offline, daily data, 2001 to 2026)

19 ETFs + Bitcoin + Ethereum, equal weights
Per yearUps and downsSharpeWorst drop
Whole period: hold all8.3%15%0.6243%
Whole period: trend rule on each5.4%8%0.7212%
Whole period: S&P 500 ETF (SPY)8.7%19%0.5456%
Last 40%: hold all11.3%15%0.7930%
Last 40%: trend rule on each7.3%8%0.9210%
Last 40%: S&P 500 ETF (SPY)12.0%19%0.7134%
7 crypto and a gold token + 7 currency pairs (currencies long or short)
Per yearUps and downsSharpeWorst drop
Whole period: hold all7.8%18%0.5147%
Whole period: trend rule on each9.5%13%0.7826%
Last 40%: hold all21.2%28%0.8247%
Last 40%: trend rule on each19.3%19%1.0126%

What it shows: spreading the same rule across many markets cut the worst drop sharply (from 43% to 12% in the ETF test, from 47% to 26% in the crypto and currency test) and improved the risk-adjusted return (Sharpe) in both tests. In the ETF test it earned less per year than holding everything, in exchange for much smaller drops. In the crypto and currency test it earned as much or nearly as much as holding, with smaller drops.

2. One market at a time: popular indicators compared

20 daily histories (18 shares and ETFs, Bitcoin, Ethereum), last 40% of each, long or cash, after costs
MethodSharpePer yearWorst drop
Buy and hold0.5713.8%45%
200-day trend rule0.5211.0%30%
Vote of nine trend signals0.508.0%25%
RSI(14) above 500.499.4%31%
Squeeze Momentum0.488.2%34%
12-month momentum0.469.7%35%
MACD cross0.456.9%31%
Ichimoku cloud / Supertrend0.437.7%29% / 33%
Breakout (Donchian 55/20)0.365.8%28%
UT Bot0.254.4%40%
Bollinger Bands / RSI mean reversion0.20 to 0.230.8% to 2.2%31% to 36%

The plain 200-day rule was the strongest single-market method we tried. Adding momentum filters, volatility sizing, stops or machine learning on top did not improve it.

3. Live: the trend portfolio on 14 markets, calculated in your browser

Loading...

Markets: Bitcoin, Ethereum, BNB, Solana, XRP, Cardano and a gold-backed token (long or cash), plus seven currency pairs (long or short). Equal weights among the markets that have enough history. A signal at the close is acted on from the next day. The live numbers differ a little from the offline table above because the calendar and the data window are not identical.

How we tested, and what to keep in mind

Charts: Lightweight Charts, an open-source library by TradingView, Inc. (Apache 2.0).